Wednesday, 18 June 2014

Second Class Citizen


It is just over one month since I decided to strip down my recurve and start shooting barebow.  In that time I have shot nine scored rounds at distances ranging from 80yds down to 40yds with mix of both imperial and metric rounds.  My first round was a Long Metric II (3doz at 70m and 3doz at 60m) for which I scored 182 giving a handicap of 67.  As this was my first attempt at 70m barebow, I initially struggled to find the correct string-walking position, but eventually found that drawing immediately below the nocking point allowed me to sight the point of my arrow at the top of the boss. 60m was better as I was able to sight on the gold with a drawing position slightly lower down the string.  For the first time out I was quite pleased at achieving a third class score.

My second and third scored rounds had to wait until Bank Holiday Monday, nine days after the first, due to other commitments, and they were both WA 70m rounds, forming a double round.  As you are probably aware, with double rounds like this, only the first of the day can be used for calculating official handicaps or for claiming (single round) records.  Of course, you can still claim a record for the double round.  This time, I had a better basis for sighting, so I had fewer misses overall on the first round, but all went-to-pot on the afternoon round, resulting in a score that was 57 lower than the morning score.  I am not really sure what happened, but maybe it was tiredness setting-in after lunch.  Whatever the reason, I was happy with second class scores (59 & 62 h/cap) for both halves (of which I could 'count' only the first).

The following evening I shot a National with a score of 264 for a handicap of 62.  The difference this time was the lower proportion of misses compared to the 70m rounds the day before.  Clearly, the shorter distance will have an effect, but I think being able to sight on the gold rather than at somewhere else above it also helps.  Anyway, I was happy with the another 2nd class score.

My next scored round the following weekend was another National.  I scored a little lower this time but managed another 62 handicap, giving my third, second class score and qualification for a Second Class award.  Looking back at the dates I realised that I had achieved this within a week.  However, looking closer at my round statistics, I could have achieved so much more.

Two of our club members are working to become AGB Level 2 coaches, and one of them approached me to ask if I would mind being one of her 'learner archers'.  I will write separate posts on the training sessions, but one of the first things we agreed was a set of achievable goals for the short, medium and long terms.  My immediate choice of short-term goal was 'less misses', as this problem has plagued me for the last few months both in recurve and barebow.  As I have just started shooting barebow, I have found it easy to put more statistics into a spreadsheet for analysis, and this time I have added the number of hits and total arrows per round, then calculated the percentage hit rate.  You can see the numbers in this table:


DateRoundScoreHandicapClassHitsArrows%HitsAdj ScoreAdj h/cap
17/05/2014Long Metric II182673rd417257%32059
26/05/2014WA 70m195592nd447261%31952
26/05/2014WA 70m13862(2nd)407256%24856
27/05/2014National264622nd567278%33957
31/05/2014National254622nd547275%33957
01/06/2014Hereford396612nd9414465%60754
03/06/2014National296602nd607283%35556
08/06/2014Short National327643rd677293%35162
15/06/2014American388632nd749082%47258

As expected, there are less hits at longer distances, but my hit rate does seem to be improving slightly.  As an exercise, I decided to calculate a notional score if I had a 100% hit rate (Adj Score), based on the average score for my actual hits and the equivalent handicap (Adj h/cap).  Two things stand out: (1) the worst adjusted handicap figure is at the shortest range and (2) four of these handicaps are at a first-class level (although not necessarily at qualifying distances).  This validates my short term goal of less misses and has given food for thought on why there appear to be problems at shorter ranges.  I have some ideas but that will have to wait until the next post.




Thursday, 15 May 2014

Back to Basics

I have decided that it is time for a change.  'But why'? I hear you ask.  Well, the bottom line is that I have not really been enjoying my archery as much as I should lately and have found myself in a bit of a rut.  You know that I have been recording my scores and handicaps for this blog, and the graph of the handicap figures on my records page tells a story.

My best shooting was during July and the back-end of August last year, when I got quite close to achieving second-class scores (handicap of 50 or less) on a couple of occasions.  However, since October, my handicap figures have headed upwards so that they are currently bouncing between third-class and unclassified, with no apparent downward trend.  I have tried some one-to-one coaching to help me with technique and clicker setup, which has helped me shoot in a more relaxed manner but it does not seem to be having the right effect on my scores.  My conclusion is that I am thinking too hard and need to simplify things.  A number of fellow club members suggested that I try barebow.

I tried barebow last week.

I liked it.

For the first time in months I felt that I was able to shoot 'instinctively', without worrying too much about aiming, back tension, etc, etc. I simply left off my sight and stabilisers and didn't use my clicker.  To aim I used what I subsequently learned was the 'gap' method, where the string is held at the nocking point (as in recurve) and aiming is by means of sighting the end of the arrow at a point below or above the gold.  At first I used trial and error and fired a lot of arrows very high over the target.  However after a while I found that I had to aim the arrow at a point on the ground halfway between the 30m shooting line and the target, which is really quite strange at first, but you do get used to it.  Once I had found my aiming point on the ground (a convenient clump of daisies) my shots became remarkably consistent, considering I was not using a sight.  I even managed what could pass as a group.

Over the week I did a little more research into barebow techniques using some basic knowledge I had picked up from other barebow archers at the club, and concluded that I should try an alternative aiming method: string walking.  The idea is that the point of the arrow is aimed at the gold on the target, but that the drawing hand is moved to a position below the nocking point to give the correct arrow elevation before release.  A position close to the nocking point will give an aiming point farther away than a position further away from the nocking point.  The key is to find the correct position for each of the distances in a round.

On Tuesday evening I decided to bite the bullet and removed my clicker and sight block altogether.  I took some advice from Dave about the basics of string walking, then took myself off to the practice range.  At 30m I again missed with the first couple of half-dozen arrows until I found the correct position of my drawing hand.  Many barebow archers who string-walk use a tab which has a vertical line of stitches, and these can be used to repeatedly gauge the correct hand position.  As I was still using my recurve platform tab, I had to rely on what I had available, so I used the width of my fingers as a guide, which was surprisingly successful.  However, the finger spacer and platform made this method quite tricky, so I went and found a basic, leather 'beginners' tab and used that for the rest of the evening.  This made measuring easier, but was much harder on the fingers so I will be ordering a barebow tab before long!

After about half an hour at 30m on the practice range I decided to see just how far I could shoot barebow, so joined some other members who were shooting a National round on the short range and had three ends remaining at 60 yards.  The first end I had six misses over the top; the next end I had three on the boss and the third end I had six scoring arrows, totalling 18 points.  It doesn't sound a lot, but is more or less what  I was getting at the same distance with my sighted recurve bow. I always found 60yds difficult - more so than 80 yds.  At 50yds I had a few misses, but managed scores of 30, 22, 26 and 22 for the four ends I attempted, giving a convenient average of 25. If this is converted to a handicap, it gives 63, which is not very far off what I was achieving at recurve.  But, as the AGB classifications for barebow differ from recurve, a handicap score of 63 equates to a second class score whereas it would be unclassified for recurve.  The 30-point end equates a handicap of 59, which is not too far off  a barebow first class score.  If you want to see the relationship between classifications and minimum handicaps, I have prepared a cross-reference table for all age groups and bowstyles.

All of this may be beginner's luck, of course, and I may fall back into bad habits.  Nevertheless I will continue as long as I am still enjoying myself and will do my best not to overthink things again.

Monday, 24 March 2014

Why is scoring a ten so hard?

At the end of an enjoyable morning's shooting yesterday, we got talking about the size of targets. I have covered this subject in an earlier blog post (Small or far Away?), but this time Martin R mused about what proportion of the target face would score a one (imperial scoring) compared with scoring a gold.  Knowing the size of a face, the number of scoring rings and the equation for the area of a circle (I knew that Engineering degree would come in useful one day), I decided to fire-up Excel and see what numbers fell out.  The results surprised me!

RingMetric
score
Imperial
score
Outside
dia(cm)
Inside
dia(cm)
Area
(sq.cm)
%area
(metric)
%area
(imperial)
Outer white11122109.82221.0719%36%
Inner White21109.897.61987.2817%
Outer black3397.685.41753.4815%28%
Inner black4385.473.21519.6813%
Outer blue5573.2611285.8911%20%
Inner blue656148.81052.099%
Outer red7748.836.6818.297%12%
Inner red8736.624.4584.495%
Outer gold9924.412.2350.73%4%
Inner gold10912.20116.91%
11689.87

Before looking at the results, it is worth looking at how the calculations are done.  I decided to work with a 122cm diameter face, the largest in common usage in target archery.  There are, of course, ten scoring rings on a standard face, two each of white, black, blue, red and gold, working from the outside inwards.  Each of these rings is the same width so it is easy to find that for a 122 cm face, each ring is 6.1cm wide (122/20).  The inner gold is the only complete circle, having a diameter of 12.2cm.

To work out the area covered by each of the rings, simply calculate the area of the circle from the outside diameter of the ring then subtract the area of the circle from the inside diameter of the ring.  If you cast your memory back to your schooldays you will recall that the area of a circle is Pi times the radius squared.  Using a spreadsheet means that you can do this fairly easily, but it might help to know that in Excel, the function PI() can be used in a function instead of typing 3.1.4159265.....

The actual areas of each of the rings are shown in the table above.  I then summed them before calculating the percentage of the total target area for each ring.

As I said earlier, the results surprised me.  What immediately stood out was the difference in percentage area of the outer white (19%) and inner gold (1%).  The 19% figure wasn't that much of a shock, but the 1% definitely was.  To score a ten, you need to almost twenty times as accurate as scoring a one.  That probably explains why I get significantly more ones than tens, and has nothing at all to do with my ability!

The other oddity I noticed was that the percentage areas form a linear progression: 1%, 3%, 5%, 7%, 9%, 11%, 13%, 15%, 17% and 19%.  There is probably a sound mathematical reason for this but I cannot work it out.  let me know if you find out!

The above calculations are based on ten-zone, metric scoring, but you can easily find out the area percentages by summing the two figures for each of the coloured scoring zones.  I have included these figures in the table above.

So, what about the smaller targets?  Clearly, the areas will be smaller, but the proportions of each of the scoring rings are identical to the 122cm face, meaning that the percentages will be the same regardless of the overall diameter.

Monday, 3 March 2014

Equipment Failure Annoyance

Mrs EA and I have decided that we are never again going to shoot on the same boss in a competition, if at all possible.  Why?  I hear you ask.

Last Saturday we took part in the King's Cup, an indoor FITA 18 competition run by Chessington Bowmen.  We regularly shoot with them in this venue and had been looking forward to the day for a while.  There were three sessions timetabled during the day and Mrs EA and I were booked into the second of the three.  Because he entered later, EA jnr was shooting in the final session of the day.

We arrived in plenty of time and set up our bows.  During practice Mrs EA found her arrows flying too high and adjusted her sight to compensate.  However, the adjustment didn't seem to be doing anything.  Eventually she realised that turning the adjustment knob did not moved the sight block as expected because the block was not free to move.

The only thing that had changed since the sight's previous outing four days earlier was that I had changed the grub screw securing the sight pin to a more robust, socket-head screw.  As an aside, I had to do this on my own sight a couple of weeks earlier because the sight pin kept shaking loose between ends, and the grub screw did not allow for sufficient tightening without burring the hex socket.  I found a suitable screw (M4) in my box-o-bits (rescued from a dead shower mixer!), but when I tried to replace the same screw in Mrs EA's sight, I found that the thread was different (M3).  They are both SF Elite Carbon sights, but hers is a few years older than mine, and there are a couple of other, minor differences if you look carefully.  I ordered a pack of 10, M3 screws from my favourite eBay supplier and fitted the screw on Friday.  The sight pin has not moved since.

Back to Saturday - Mrs EA was getting more and more frustrated at her sight not being adjustable and it was affecting her performance.  Her blaming me for the problem was affecting mine!  I did manage to moved the sight block enough for her to get some accuracy, but she did not regain her confidence.  I was distracted enough to pull my arrows before scoring on one end! We both ended with our worst-ever scores for the FITA 18 round and the only saving grace is that I didn't come last.  Whilst putting away our kit we noticed that we seemed to be the only couple who were shooting on the same boss, so we have decided to request being separated in future!

Having written-off our session we sat down to watch EA jnr in his.  This was his first time scoring an indoor round shooting compound and he was the only junior compound entry.  The other three compound archers on his boss are all very capable, so any bad shots from him would be apparent.  He ended with a score of 445, which is very creditable given the circumstances, and it put my score of 275 in stark contrast.  As the only competitor in his class, he was awarded gold medals for the session and for the overall competition.  Some might say that he got them by default, but many people were impressed by his performance and were surprised that he had only been shooting compound for less than a month.  Because there are so few junior compound archers around us, he will be setting new club and county records rather than breaking them, but I guess someone has to be the first. Perhaps it may spur other juniors to try compound, too.

Back home after the competition I took a good look at the offending sight and I think the problem was a combination of things.  The previous weekend, Mrs EA had tightened the retaining screws that pass through the block onto the vertical track because the block was wobbling.  This did not cause any problems until the block was moved to the very top of the track, where it wedged.  Any attempt to use the screw adjustment resulted in a click and no movement.  By the liberal application of some WD40 and the use of an old toothbrush, I cleaned out the block and removed a lot of dirt from the threaded rod.  The block now moves freely again.  The prospect of having to buy a replacement sight on top of all of the other changes was not very welcome, but this one is clearly reaching the end of its (reliable) life.   Mrs EA has hinted that it could be a good birthday present, so I have until July to save some pennies.

Domestic bliss has been restored.


Tuesday, 25 February 2014

All change on the equipment front

The last few weeks has seen a large turnover of archery kit in our household, mainly due to Christmas and two birthdays (mine and EA jnr).  Mrs EA has also upgraded.

So what has changed for me?  Santa Claus brought me a backpack case to replace the hard case I had inherited from Mrs EA, and an Easton quiver and belt to replace the cast-off I had been using.  The backpack case now holds all of my kit except the quiver (as I don't want to fold it) and seems to make bow assembly and disassembly more efficient.  I no longer have to go scrabbling around in a separate bag for my stand or sight, and the integral arrow tube means one less thing to carry.

The end of January sees my birthday on the 29th and EA jnr's birthday on the 30th.  Mrs EA gifted me a pair of limbs bought second-hand from eBay and I received some cash gifts that have gone towards buying a new set of arrows and a new button.  The button is a Shibuya DX and the limbs are SF Premium Carbon limbs with a nominal draw weight of 28lbs, a small increase on the 24lb limbs I have been using since the start of the last summer season.  Before fitting the new limbs, I measured the actual draw weight of my bow with the old limbs and found it to be 29lb.  This sounds high, but the riser limb bolts were adjusted right in and I do have a longer draw than the nominal 28".  I adjusted the limb bolts right out before putting on the new limbs and found that the new draw weight was 30lb - not very different to what I am used to but with plenty of scope for increasing over the next few months.

The arrows were ordered as components: 10x Easton ACC 3-04 shafts cut to 28.5", 80g parabolic points, red/white/blue EP16 vanes and white Easton G-nocks (small).  The delivery of the arrow components turned into a saga of problems, with some items being out of stock, wrong points being sent and used items being sent out as new.  The retailer has held up his hands and been very apologetic, to the point of losing a couple of staff for incompetence.  I am still waiting for a couple of items, but I know that this is out of his control and I did have enough components to make a usable set of arrows.

I shot the ACCs for the first time indoors this week without adjusting my bow, and was really quite pleased with the result.  The flatter trajectory was apparent as I had to adjust my sight up from my previous sight mark for 20yds.  This weekend I intend to fit my new button and go through the exercise of tuning the bow properly, maybe slightly increasing the draw weight.  Once that is done I will need to get new sight marks for all distances again!

EA jnr has undergone an even more radical change - he is now shooting a compound bow rather than recurve.  Aged 14, he has more growing to do so it was important to get a bow that can grow with him, but that he will not outgrow too soon.  We sought the advice of Dave, a very experienced compound archer at our club and we independently decided that a Mission Menace bow seemed a good choice.  Along with the bow, we bought a second-hand sight through the Archery Equipment for Sale UK group (thanks, Jon!) and a release aid and scope from Dave.  Dave also donated a bow bag that had been cluttering the loft (or so he says), and gave up his Saturday morning set the bow up properly.

This left EA jnr's recurve kit redundant, so we offered it as a complete set to one of the club's new juniors, who was delighted to leave the field totally equipped.

Finally, Mrs EA bought a new set of limbs (the same type as mine but shorter and higher poundage) and a used Win&Win Winact riser from another club member.  She is still getting used to the new setup and has yet to reach the same level of performance she had reached before the change.

I think that is going to be it on the equipment front for a while, unless I start doing the lottery!




Thursday, 9 January 2014

New Year, New Goals

Happy New Year!  With the passing of 2013 I thought it was high time that I put fingers to keyboard and put together a quick review of my year in archery.  Actually, it isn't quite a year as the first lesson of my beginner's course was on 26 January, and a lot has happened since.

Looking back, I think I can say that I have made some good progress.  I am never going to become an Olympian and there is plenty of room for improvement. However the improvement in my handicap over the last year (80 to 53) was one of the best in the club so I am quite pleased.  As I did not have a handicap at the start of 2013, I am not eligible for the GNAS Handicap Improvement Medal, but Mrs EA is one of the four members who will be having a shoot-off this weekend to decide the winner.

So what were the best bits of my first year in archery?  Above all, I have to say that the very best part of last year was meeting and shooting with a great bunch of people and making some very good friends.  There is nothing to beat having a chinwag between ends, and it's nice to get together away from the field, too.

Also high on my list is having entered three external competitions: two outdoors and one indoors.  If you haven't shot outside you club yet, don't be daunted and have a go - the organizers are usually very helpful and the more experienced archers are always encouraging to newbies.  If you are with other members from your club so much the better.

At this time of year it as also fashionable (me? fashionable?) to outline your goals for the forthcoming year, so here goes.

1. Improve my consistency

2. Achieve my 2nd class classification

3. Regularly shoot at 70m and above

4. Enter at least three outside competitions


The first of these is the least measurable of all of the goals, so I had better explain what I mean.  Over that past three or four months I have not been able to shoot as often as I would like and I have noticed a definite downturn in my performance from my best of last summer, and this is borne-out if you look at the graph on my shooting records page.  Some of this is definitely down to poor technique and the return of bad habits, but I also think that I am pushing my current equipment to its limits, especially at 60m and above, so I will be looking to upgrade my arrows from aluminium XX75 to aluminium/carbon composite.  In a few months I may also upgrade my limbs in terms of both draw weight and quality.

I am hoping that the lighter arrows will give me better consistency at longer distances and thus enable me to shoot lower handicap scores.  Second class requires shooting at a handicap of 50 and, at my best, this is definitely within reach.  The jump to first class (handicap of 44) is a much bigger ask, and requires consistent shooting at 70m, so this may be a step too far.  However, it will not stop me having a go!  If you are wondering where I got the classification figures, I used Google to find this page.

Last year I volunteered as Field Crew at the Surrey County Championships, which takes place over a weekend in July, and this year I intend to enter.  I turn 50 at the end of January so I will be eligible to shoot in the Masters class, which is a 70m round.  Senior archers under 50 must shoot a 90m round, which will probably be beyond me at that time.  There are a number of other competitions that I will also enter.  I am unlikely to win any silverware, but I will enjoy the day.

Finally, I think I should add one more goal:

5. Don't leave it more than two months before your next post!

Good shooting!


Monday, 14 October 2013

From 18m to 80yds

Just when I thought is was all getting a bit samey, I managed to shoot for new rounds for the first time in the space of a fortnight, ranging from an 18m indoor round to an 80yd outdoor round.

The first new round was a FITA 18, which we shot at our club's temporary indoor venue.  Whilst 18m is the shortest distance I have shot indoors, it comes with the additional challenge of having a 40cm face , rather than the 60m face used on Portsmouth rounds at 20yds.  Being a new distance for me, I had no sight marks, but just made an estimate from previous 20yd figures.  At 10 dozen, the round is the same length as a Portsmouth, but expected scores for a specific handicap are much lower for a FITA 18 than for a Portsmouth.  I am still trying to work on my technique and concentrating on using my back muscles and sometimes this goes horribly wrong, but I was pleased with my score of 402, giving a handicap figure of 52 - my best yet and much lower than my current indoor running handicap.

The following week was another indoor FITA, this time a FITA 25. As the name suggests, this is shot from 25m but, unlike the FITA 18, at a 60cm face.  The expected scores for a specific handicap are much lower than for a Portsmouth, but slightly higher than a FITA 18.  (I don't envy those folk who have to calculate these handicap figures!).  My score this time was 382 (55 h/cap) so not as good as the FITA 18, but still my third Class E score.

The following weekend we were back outdoors.  The weather was overcast, but totally windless, so I made the brave decision to have my first attempt a Long National at 80yds.  If you have read my previous post on my adventures at 70m, you will know that it was not altogether successful!  However, I did remember that I had adjusted my sight for the shorter indoor distances, so I moved it back to allow for the longer distance.  The first two or three sighters fell well short, even when my sight was set so low that the sight pin risked fouling the arrow on release, so I decided to aim higher than the gold and managed to get some arrows on the boss.  I eventually found that aiming at the fabric of the flag above the boss gave me a fairly consistent hit rate, but I found myself still aiming at the gold from time to time.

After the four dozen at 80yds, the two dozen at 60yds seemed relatively easy and I ended up with a score bang on my running handicap, which pleased me no end.  What does puzzle me is that on subsequent rounds starting at 60yds, it seemed an awful lot harder than coming down from 80yds to 60yds.  I guess it is that old chestnut of archery being all in the mind!